Want to order over the phone?
Call (424) 293-0474
Thank you for being with us!
We will call you back!
Want to order over the phone?
Call (424) 293-0474
4:00 pm
4:00 pm
4:00 pm
4:00 pm
10" Small 6
12" Medium 10
14" Large 13
16" Family 15
10" Small 6
12" Medium 10
14" Large 13
16" Family 15
10" Small 7
12" Medium 11
14" Large 14
16" Family 16
10" Small 8
12" Medium 12
14" Large 15
16" Family 17
10" Small 10
12" Medium 14
14" Large 17
16" Family 19
beef, bacon, cheddar and mozzarella cheese
ham, pineapple, mozzarella cheese
taco beef, mozzarella cheese, topped with picante sauce, lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream and cheddar
italian sausage, roasted pepper and onions, mozzarella cheese
marinated artichoke hearts, mushrooms, onions, mozzarella cheese
black and green olives, garlic, feta cheese, olive oil, mozzarella cheese and fresh tomatoes
bar-b-que sauce, pineapple, smoked pulled pork, mozzarella cheese
hot wing sauce, roasted chicken, mozzarella cheese and crispy bacon
Creamy Alfredo sauce, spinach, mushrooms, roasted chicken, mozzarella cheese, bacon, and fresh tomatoes
10" small 8
12" medium 12
14" large 15
16" family 17
Do you have gluten free crust as an option??
Excellent pizza and very fast window service.
My wife and I wanted to try something different, so we tried the barbecue pizza, it was great. Our kids ate a pepperoni pizza and I got a slice of it and it was great too. Prices are good the people are friendly
MoreAwesome pizza at a great price. They have a carry out special that is terrific. Friendly staff. Order early as they can get busy.
MoreBest pizza EVER!!!
Best pizza anywhere near Oak Island! They make excellent specialty pizzas. They Mexican and the BBQ pizzas are family favorites. This is a cash only establishment though, so be sure to hit the ATM before you pick up your order. Highly recommend giving it a try.
MoreIts allways good
Everyone was very friendly! The portions and price were great!! Will deffinetly be back when in the area!
MoreThis place has delicious but non trad pizzas. Crust tastes like sourdough and matzah had a kid. It tastes just like the pizzas I had in Greensboro, N.C. growing up at a place called the Ol Miner. Similar smokey big flavor pepperoni. Delicious cheese! Such a beautiful coincidence as the Ol' Miner closed down in the 1990's. This pizza allows me to recapture an earlier time in my life, such a gift to eat their pizza everytime I come to the beach! I strongly reccomend the pepperoni with extra cheese. And their bbq is bold in flavor as well. This is flavor saver central baby! Don't miss these unique pizzas and bbq!!
MoreIf you can find better pizza than pizza Shack let me know please! They make the best pizza EVER!!!
MoreGreat pizza and quick service. Little hole in the wall place.
Always good pizza. Made by hand. I've eaten here countless times, and I've never been disappointed.
MoreGreat pizza!! The crust is amazing!!
Really good pizza! Domino's had a 3 hour wait and Pizza Shack got us our pizza in 20 mins!!! Shop local!
MoreLike this pizza. Good crust & sauce. Like how they put toppings under cheese so thru don't fall off.
MoreBest pizza on the island, yummy, and friendly staff.
Food was delivered exactly when it was supposed to be. Was delicious. Driver was very friendly. Reasonably priced. Will eat here again. You should too.
MoreBest Mexican pizza ever! Great folks!
They don't accept debit or credit cards? The person who answered was extremely nice but I had to go elsewhere because I don't carry cash! Sad I really wanted to try their pizza...ooh well
More$30 for 2 "large" pizzas. They couldn't have been more than 12" and tasted like a Tony's frozen pizza. RIP OFF. SAVE YOUR MONEY. Go to pepperoni grill, its WAY better pizza for a WAY better value.
MoreIf you want the best priced and tasting pizza in the area, then you can't go wrong with the shack.
MoreBest pizza on the island by far...dont you dare go to Dominos.
Worse than the school pizza we had as a kid. By far the worst pizza crust I've ever had. Bland/canned sauce. Good/fast/walk-up service though and some of the toppings were fine, which saves them a star.
MoreWe drove 2 hours from Fayetteville Nc to try it and we were very pleased with the food and service.
MoreGreat place to get pizza on the island! One of the few places that is worth the money. Crust is handtossed and sauce is amazing! I recommend it for your pizza craving after a long day on the beach!
MoreGreat crust! Ingredients were fresh! Definitely going to be our “go to” oak island pizza!
MoreOur first time here and we loved it
Pizza was good, but our pepperoni pizza came with only 9 pepperonis. So thats like 1 and an 1/8th roni per slice. Edit: I’m editing this because upon further investigation the pepperoni is under the cheese. I’m sorry for my misconceptions.
MoreDry wings, food was meh, tiny meatballs. Shorted me a drink on delivery....
So good! Friendly staff, I suggest the taco pizza :)
Must try their mexican Pizza as well as their Bacon Cheese Pizza, borh arw awesome, so many toppings and so much cheese!
MoreBeen wanting to try this pizza for years, man was it goooood. Will be back soon.
Awesome pizza. Worth the wait!
We love pizza shack pizza; one of our favorites! Thin cracker like crust and minimal sauce with lots of toppings and cheese!!
MoreWe got pizza for our family from here twice during our week-long visit to the beach. The pizza was good and at an affordable price. They do not skimp on the cheese! The staff was great when I went to pick up the pizzas. You could tell this was a family business operated with pride.
MoreBest pizza....hands down! Only place that we’ve EVER had our pizza delivered and it’s so hot that you have to let it cool off. Delicious!
MoreGreat pizza with fresh ingredients. We love it!
Frozen pizza probably better. Service was good.Canned mushrooms, sausage so so. Go up north and try pizza if you like this one.
MoreVery Good Pizza. Noticed the sign driving by and stopped in. Not disappointed.
Best pizza around. Hands down. Kid named BLake was awsome
Great Taco pizza !!!
One of the best pizzas around! Can't be beat!
Best pizza I’ve ever had and amazing and friendly customer service! Just know they only take cash or check and no debit/credit cards though
MoreGreat crust and sauce, generous toppings and cheese; very reasonable delivery time!!
MoreMy favorite pizza place....never disappointed in the pizza....wait time can be long during tourist season but that is to be expected
MorePizza was excellent. very fast delivery. fairly cheap. delivery guy was very friendly and so was the lady on the phone. definitely recommend if you ever come to oki.
MoreDelivered by gentleman with a beautiful heart. We don’t remember his name but will never forget his kindness to our kids - especially our little guy on his 2nd birthday. Pizza good too!
MoreGreat pizza and great service. Only drawback is they don't accept credit/debit card. Ordered a 14" supreme and two 10" pies, total cost: $33.. Ate a rivals pizza earlier this week. It was good. Pizza Shack was MUCH better.
MoreFantastic Pizza and we appreciate you getting our order in just before closing.
All around great experience. Pizza was delicious and hot. Service was fast. Best pizza I’ve had on the island.
MoreThe Mexican pizza was the best I ever had and very nice service everyone in there was asking if we had everything we needed
More